Don’t Rock the Boat
I’m tired. Can I just name that? The wonky sleep of advancing years. Trying to hang onto joy in these times that shatter my heart, over and over. (I wish I could say everything seems worse in the middle of the night, but in this case it’s bad and badder all the time.) Fretting about the need to clean out the house, but doing little about it, while the literal and metaphorical clocks tick.
Abigail Thomas, who is eighty-five, wrote in a recent post: “Sometimes you wake up at four-thirty in the morning with a surge of energy and no cows to milk.” Gawd, I wish my waking hour were four-thirty; but no, it’s one-thirty. What do you do with one-thirty? Slip another melatonin tablet under the tongue and hope for a couple more hours? I have “cows,” I’m editing a memoir—and cleaning out the house. But not at one-thirty.
My internet was down for a week and a half this month. Well, down during “peak time,” which seemed to be from seven a.m. until sometime after I went to bed. Which partnered well with sleeplessness, what with getting up at four o’clock—unless I had finally gone back to sleep about then—and trying to think of everything I needed that day from the information highway before it went out again.
On the one hand, I often blame the internet for, well, everything happening globally. At the same time, I am personally dependent on it for so much. I find it tedious, and sometimes impossible, to conduct life on my phone. I kept thinking it was temporary, though there was no report of a widespread outage. Surely it wasn’t a problem with my equipment or my line, since it worked sometimes. Reddit suggested my “node” was oversold.
All to say, I didn’t contact customer support.
I have a lifelong reticence to rocking boats. Big boats, such as relationship obstacles; small boats such as anything involving talking on the phone. Hoping all of it will magically resolve in silence. I would rather live with stuff than risk shame or embarrassment or a negative reaction. I would rather cheer for miraculous, or have a root canal, than stir things up. I’m a nine on the Enneagram: the peacemaker—or the peacekeeper.
I learned from the cradle.
My sisters and I are trying to clean out our family home. (Reminder: my father died in 1995, my mother eight years ago. And here we still are.) One afternoon a month—well, not really, but that was the goal—we gather to go through a box or two. This month it was a legal-size banker’s box chock full of my mother’s calendars, greeting cards, journals, copies of letters, and unmailed letters. Oh, the unsent letters. Processing her angst about her adult children over and over for years.
Her journal entries were written in spiral notebooks, or on single sheets. (She didn’t use the journals
we gave her because “they were too pretty to write sadness in.”) The unmailed letters poured out in stationery pads or on onionskin paper; in her beautiful penmanship and in shorthand. Paper was filled day-after-day, month-after-month for years, trying to work out her feelings over how my younger sister and I (first serially, then in tandem) had blown up our lives, wondering what she had done wrong.
She never risked breaching our already distant—physical and emotional—relationship to talk about it; bottling it up inside instead. Had she, I would not have wanted to engage. Given our dearth of experience, I have no doubt we would have ended up more estranged. Which is not to say I didn’t know how she felt.
It took us four hours, even skimming. Some would argue to just throw it out without looking at it. They would not be wrong, but we can’t do that. Our parents are gone, this is the last opportunity to touch them. On June 21, the day my father unexpectedly died—the day after my forty-third birthday—our mother wrote two lines in her 1995 Sierra Club calendar: “Oh, George. I will miss you—suddenly the world seems so empty.” Our father’s full calendar suddenly stopped. It broke our collective heart.
My sister and I believe that our presence with our mother during the last years of her life healed all wounds. Though it was hard to read her toxic writings, mostly we grieved that she let anguish control her living for so long. She blamed her “bad parenting” for our actions, rather than see that we were capable women making our unique way through the world, owning our mistakes and cheering our successes. We were not clones. She and I measured successful parenting on different scales.
✉️ ✉️ ✉️
I finally called CenturyLink. They sent a technician three days later. He reprogrammed the box on the wall outside the house, behind the espaliered forsythia—which I didn’t know was there—and said it wasn’t running at the speed I was paying for. It’s great now, even working faster than it ever has. I called and asked for a credit on my bill during the time it was out (so brave), but only got it for the time since I placed the call. Company policy. I should have rocked that canoe sooner, not waited until I knew it wasn’t going to return to shore on its own.
We plan to burn the letters, releasing us all. Especially our mother.
Every day is Mother’s Day. Blessings on you and yours.
I would love to hear from you! Are you a rocker or a steady sailor? Do you have a story? Leave a comment below.
A note about commenting on a post: Click the subscribe drop down arrow just above the comment section and provide your information (it’s private) to receive an email when someone replies to your comment. I, at least, will always reply!





Thanks for writing, thanks for sharing. Every time I read one of your eLetters I feel as though I am gaining some insight into my own life.
I’m so glad for that, Deb. It’s the whole reason for memoir! Thank you.
“We were not clones.” Now there’s a mouthful!
Indeed.
Beautiful piece Gretchen, so moving. Me, I was born to rock the boat, but also find myself in fits of silence and letting be. I’m reminded of Warren Zevon’s song, Mutineer.
I was born to rock the boat
Some may sink but we will float
Grab your coat, let’s get out of here
You’re my witness
I’m your mutineer
“I’m your mutineer.” Love that. Speaking out in dissent or alternative viewpoint was asking to be strung and hung in my family! Also, thank you.
This reminds me of a time, about five years ago, when I was sitting with my then 85-year-old mother in her apartment at a senior living place in Iowa. We were looking at, and talking about her “stuff.” I had just told her she should mark what she wanted me to have and get rid of the rest. (She, like StellaJoe, saved EVERYTHING as well as blamed herself for all the wrong turns I’d made in my life, primarily that I didn’t have ANY Martha Stewart skills, or have children. But that’s a whole other story.) She said to me that day, “When I die, you are just going to get rid of all this stuff, aren’t you?” I looked back at her, took a deep breath, blinked, and replied, “No, I’m going to PAY SOMEONE to come in here and dispose of everything. So if you want me to have something in particular, you better either mark it, or gift it before you go. Because I am not going to handle all.this.stuff.” She stared back at me, shocked and wide-eyed, and that was the last conversation we have had about it all. But, a few weeks later, after I had returned to my home 2,000 miles away, in the mail I received a large box. Inside was EVERY HALLMARK BIRTHDAY NAPKIN and EVERY BIRTHDAY CARD I had received from family and friends from ALL the birthday parties she had thrown for me from age 1 to about 15, when my athletic habits and training schedules didn’t allow time (or cake!!) for more birthday parties. All the cards, in typical Midwestern non-emotive expression just said: Dear Pam: Hallmark birthday verse, signed Uncle Marv or Aunt Betty or whomever sent the card. My husband and I had a good guffaw over this and then he took the ENTIRE box to the recycling transfer station the next day. And I’ve never had another conversation with her about this topic.
Napkins! Oh my goodness! Oh the cards with only a signature, kept for decades. My mother went one further, signing in pencil so the card could be reused. My sister wishes we had just said “yes, I’ll take [whatever],” accepted and thrown out. It would have saved us seeing it all again! Dozens of leftover copies of wedding announcements. What in the world??
I am engaged in looking at my mom’s remaining paperwork because it makes her a person, not just my mother. But she wasn’t mean about me so it doesn’t hurt to read what she has left behind. I wish I had talked to her more to understand what her life had meant to her. I still can’t throw out her unfinished masters thesis, even though the topic is boring to me. I wonder what did it mean to her? Maybe I am learning more about her life and thoughts after her death than I knew when she was alive. Before death, she was my critical mom. After death, she became a person who thought about more things than her and me.
I too know much more about my mother from what she left behind. I’m ever so slightly less snarky about it.
Reading your post reminded me again how honestly you write about things people hide. And how helpful it is to me!
I wondered if your mother’s negativity has the power to crush you still or if you remind yourself daily what a gift you gave her by being there so much in her end, despite her meanness?
I, too, am reading my mother’s journals. She was not so expressive in writing and I dig deep to find an emotional statement. Instead she is like a Farmer’s Almanac recording just the “facts”. A little emotion seeps through or I remember when she spoke about an event. Like you, she “would rather live with stuff than risk shame or embarrassment or a negative reaction”. She put up with a lot but it did not mean she was more content with life. The stuff she probably stuffed down did haunt her.
Did you have any sense that she was proud or grateful of you in her end? I read your book and I know it was hard on you. I still say loudly, you were her angel! You were the one who committed and were there for her, not your sisters. You are the one who bore the brunt of her continuing sharp tongue and bad mood. If you believe in Heaven, there is a really special place for a daughter like you.
I think it creates a sense of being tired, even long after our mothers die and we were their primary support. I hope you can give yourself “credit” and get a little energy from that acknowledgment of your special contribution to her life. I hope you can say proudly, “I was my mother’s angel.”
Thank you for writing, Lynet. She never really had the power to crush me. “Gretchen gets so angry. She needs counseling.” Yep, I own it. Brief anger kept me from being crushed, however inappropriate it may have been. I’m proud of what my sister and I gave her, and I think she was grateful, even if she couldn’t say it very often. Cognitive decline, perhaps, made her unable to either shut off negative filters or express gratitude. I recognize that. She didn’t mail the letters, to her credit; but I will never understand why she seemingly knowingly/purposefully kept them for me to find. All is mystery. All is forgiven.
I’m a boat-rocker from way back. As a middle kid it felt almost like a rite of passage and I rocked the crap out of that boat. I’m not crazy about confrontation either but survival is survival. Being desperate to break free of comparison to either sibling was just the motivation I needed. To this day I’m not like either of them and I owe it all to boat skills. 😊 This post reminded me that I once held onto a letter my mother wrote me that she DID mail, that was soul-crushing. I chose to let it go too. In the end what did hanging onto it prove? Not a damn thing. (I confess I have another letter or two in my world, equally soul-crushing, that I need to add to a big bonfire too.) Cheers to the freedom of letting go.
Cheers for boat-rocking! I’ve never understood why my father–on the debate team in his youth–was so loathe to “discuss alternate viewpoints” with me. Why didn’t he teach me how to debate, instead of cutting off all dissent? I have questions.
I am definitely a steady sailor! And I avoid phone calls at all costs!!! I rarely return anything to the store and if I do, I always have my speech ready as to why. Of course they never ask and just refund the money.
As for journals, I kept one when my children were young. I wrote in it daily. When my kids were grown, I reread them. They seemed to be mostly negative!!! It wasn’t because I was miserable (I was NOT) but because it was easier to write things down than to say “I am tired of being a mother and wife!” It was hard work. The complaints were trivial. When good things happened I could share them with everyone but when I was tired of washing diapers I wrote it down. I did not want my children reading my whining entries and I burned the journals so they wouldn’t have to read about them. The only reason that I would have liked to have them now is so that I could have my daughter look at them and see that all mothers sometimes resent their kids and the role they have chosen.But I had a great life and try to share that with them as much as possible!
I always love hearing from you, Anna. Thank you for the story.